Dustin and Mariya Oldfather


We have built the top selling real estate office in southern Delaware, responsible for a team with more than $100 million in sales.   Our office ranks in the top five and our numbers continue to grow as the local market also continues to grow.

Our path to owning an insurance agency comes from our passion to offer the most professional level of customer service and client care.  As our team helps numerous homeowners find their dream home, we felt there was more we could do to serve our customers.  Establishing We Insure Prosperity fulfilled that passion by furthering our service by protecting your homes and possessions. 

We Insure Prosperity, is a one stop insurance agency offering home, auto, business insurance and much more.  Our agency has partnerships with multiple top-rated insurance companies, offering great product choices and competitive rates.  Equipped with advanced technology, our team will lead you through the insurance process in a fast and comprehensive experience.  Buy online, over the phone, via email or in person at our office.

Address Icon


16394 Paynters Mill Blvd
Ste 202
Milton , DE 19968
Office Hours Icon


Monday - Friday 9 am - 5pm
Weekend by Appointment