Your Tampa, FL Insurance Agent

We Insure Tampa Bay

Address Icon


13919 Carrolwood Village Run
Office 5
Tampa, FL 33618

Office Hours Icon

Office Hours

M-F: 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m
S-S: By Appointment Only

Every coverage type for every type of customer

We Insure Tampa Bay


We Insure Tampa Bay is a one stop insurance agency offering home, auto, business insurance, and much more.  We have partnerships with over 100 of the top-rated insurance companies to get you the proper coverage and affordable premiums that meet your needs. 

Our agency has a passion for providing an exceptional level of service to our customers.   We have an experienced team that will lead you through the insurance process in a fast and comprehensive experience.  Equipped with the advanced technology and the most access to carriers, We Insure Tampa Bay can provide our customers choice, speed, convenience, and the confidence that they are protected. 

Schedule a time to discuss your policy!

Your local We Insure team

Kaitlyn Arrington

Agency Owner

(813) 579-1605

Your local We Insure reviews

Read More Reviews
ray cruz
It was a pleasure working with Marissa Gero, she was extremely attentive and her service was truly 5 star!
mike ganas
When searching for insurance it has been hard to find an agent that displays a high level of professionalism and transparency about the product you are purchasing. For years I just bought what I thought I needed and trusted what they said I needed. If you're anything like I am, understanding all of the options on a policy can be difficult. Alexander helped me every step of the way and was able to take the time to actually explain exactly what I was purchasing! I now know what my needs are and feel as if I actually understand what I have purchased with confidence. Any time I had a question he was able to answer it in a short time. I even got a better rate than I previously had with my old agent. I plan on using his knowledge for my home owners as well!
Charles Pflueger
Angela and her team are the best insurance agents I’ve ever dealt with.
Kevin Dehlinger
Angela and Brittany are extremely knowledgeable and professional. They have great communication and most importantly, saved multiple family members money on their insurance! Highly recommend!
Rita Weaver
Great service! Fast and knowledgeable! Will recommend to anyone.
Marie Garfinkel
Ms Arrington was very very helpful in working with me to obtain the best possible homeowners insurance policy that works with my needs
Dennis Bulat
Great service
Douglas Woods
You and your team made this search easy . Thank you .
Brittany was absolutely incredible throughout our entire home buying experience and handled all of ourHomeowners insurance needs and questions quickly and efficiently! It was a joy working with her.
Lilly Sherwood
Kaitlyn was absolutely amazing to work with. She helped my elderly mother with a homeowners policy that included all the coverage she needed as well as a great rate. She was patient and knowledgeable when answering all of the questions we had. We will only be using her moving forward. Thanks again, Kaitlyn!
Courtney Budin
Angela has been amazing to work with!!! She is always available, very knowledgeable & trustworthy! Will definitely continue to refer clients & do business with this company!
Jackie Turek
Angela was so helpful when we were shopping for insurance. She helped us choose the best coverage and saved us money. We highly recommend We Insure Tampa Bay.
Dwain Kue
Marissa was great to work with. She was responsive, caring, and informative. She definitely helped relieve some of the stress of moving to Florida.
Katie Kanehl
Angela and Brittany are the BEST! They’re professional and a pleasure to deal with. They always have answers for me and are quick to respond to my emails and phone calls.
Douglas Ford
Kaitlyn did a great job!
Christopher Courson
Marissa and Kaitlyn were very helpful.
Marylisa Barnes
Jenn was great! She went out of her way to ensure we were taken care of in the most professional manner. We are very pleased with our experience!
Alyn Anier
Christopher Roberts
Jay Day
I live out of state and was purchasing a condo in Florida. I needed to get two policies and Kaitlyn was amazing to work with. She was extremely responsive and provided me multiple options. I strongly recommend using her for all of your insurance needs!