Your Local Insurance Agent

We Insure Tampa Bay

Address Icon


13919 Carrolwood Village Run
Office 5
Tampa, FL 33618

Office Hours Icon

Office Hours

M-F: 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m
S-S: By Appointment Only

Download Zogo

Download on the Apple App Store Badge Get it on Google Play Badge

Access code: WEINSURE

Every coverage type for every type of customer

We Insure Tampa Bay


We Insure Tampa Bay is a one stop insurance agency offering home, auto, business insurance, and much more.  We have partnerships with over 100 of the top-rated insurance companies to get you the proper coverage and affordable premiums that meet your needs. 

Our agency has a passion for providing an exceptional level of service to our customers.   We have an experienced team that will lead you through the insurance process in a fast and comprehensive experience.  Equipped with the advanced technology and the most access to carriers, We Insure Tampa Bay can provide our customers choice, speed, convenience, and the confidence that they are protected. 

Your local We Insure team

Kaitlyn Arrington

Agency Owner

Gail Peterson

Customer Service Representative

Your local We Insure reviews

Read More Reviews
Lilly Sherwood
Kaitlyn was absolutely amazing to work with. She helped my elderly mother with a homeowners policy that included all the coverage she needed as well as a great rate. She was patient and knowledgeable when answering all of the questions we had. We will only be using her moving forward. Thanks again, Kaitlyn!
Ron Hill
Angela was able to find me a better homeowner's policy and save me $500 a year. Great customer service and handled everything as far as transitioning from one company to the other. I have and will continue to refer friends and family.
Kayla L
We just bought our first home and Kaitlyn helped us find the best homeowners insurance policy for us! She is extremely knowledgeable and provided us with a wealth of insight throughout the process. She was also very attentive and kind to work with!
Jessie Rodriguez
I worked with Angela Duncan for the Homeowners insurance on our first home which we are in the middle of closing on, she made the whole process so simple and easy and was available to answer any and all questions I had! Really a pleasure to work with! She got us a great deal on homeowners with great coverage!
Quenton Richardson
We Insure staff is great! They have done a great job for my clients and always keeping me in the loop with each transaction! Brittany goes out of her way to ensure each client is satisfied and explains everything in detail throughout the process. Highly recommend them for all your insurance needs!
Laura Perry
I would highly recommend Angela Duncan as a broker with We Insure Tampa Bay. She is extremely dedicated and is always searching for the best options for her clients.
Timothy Pawloski
Zoey went above and beyond to answer all my many calls and answer all my questions to help me understand how Florida insurance works and helped me apply as many discounts as possible to save me money. I shoppel around and she came up with the best value. She really earned my business!!!
John Verstappen
I must admit for starters I know very little about Home Owners insurance. But your company made my decision on what policy to go with very easy and understandable. I will recommend you in the future.
Judith Liskin-Gasparro
Zoey Kettel was wonderful to work with!
Darwin Lalone
very nice experience. good people to work with.
Doug Foster
Great help in finding me a condo policy
Rosemarie Fitzgerald
Kaitlyn Arrington was very helpful in providing us with the best options for our needs. She was informative and thorough. We felt very confident in her.
ray cruz
It was a pleasure working with Marissa Gero, she was extremely attentive and her service was truly 5 star!
Karen MacCormack
I'm closing on a new condo next week and Angela took the time to sit and compare other quotes with me and we came up with a policy for my specific needs. I'm very pleased with the promptness and quick education on insurance.
Tiffany Dodge
Kaitlyn was quick to respond and provide a quote. Best offer I was presented for rental home insurance.
Lauren Wells
Angela Duncan was great to work with and it was completely seamless, she met every deadline with no problem and definitely kept me posted throughout the process.
Chris Brown
Zoey did an AWESOME job getting us setup with home owners and flood insurance for our recent move from out of state (Indiana) to Riverview, FL - she was/is totally THE BEST and I'd highly recommend working with her and We Insure Tampa Bay!!
Nina Papy
Kaitlyn Arrington has been an outstanding insurance agent for my family. She has ensured that we have the most competitive insurance rate for our home, vehicles and rv. I highly recommend others to call her for a quote.
Theodore Ball
I would like to say that I was extremely pleased with the help I received from Kaitlyn Arrington. The service I received was far above the norm, and I will be telling all my friends and family about the friendly, warm and professionalism of the staff at WE-INSURE office at 6320 South Dale Mabry Highway.
It was all done for me I just had to decide which policy was right for me.