Your Tampa, FL Insurance Agent

We Insure Tampa Bay

Address Icon


13919 Carrolwood Village Run
Office 5
Tampa, FL 33618

Office Hours Icon

Office Hours

M-F: 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m
S-S: By Appointment Only

Every coverage type for every type of customer

We Insure Tampa Bay


We Insure Tampa Bay is a one stop insurance agency offering home, auto, business insurance, and much more.  We have partnerships with over 100 of the top-rated insurance companies to get you the proper coverage and affordable premiums that meet your needs. 

Our agency has a passion for providing an exceptional level of service to our customers.   We have an experienced team that will lead you through the insurance process in a fast and comprehensive experience.  Equipped with the advanced technology and the most access to carriers, We Insure Tampa Bay can provide our customers choice, speed, convenience, and the confidence that they are protected. 

Schedule a time to discuss your policy!

Your local We Insure team

Kaitlyn Arrington

Agency Owner

(813) 579-1605

Your local We Insure reviews

Read More Reviews
Kelli Renew
Angela and her team did an amazing with communication and finding the best quote for my family. We now have more coverage for way less than what we were paying!
Rachel Withers May
We insure is my #1 pick for home owner insurance. Local people with your best interest in mind.
Gregg Matschke
Angela Duncan looks after me as a customer.
Glenna Dickman
Kaitlyn Arrington makes the whole process super easy..she is a super fast responder snd easy to get ahold so glad to have been referred to her…now i dont have to dread shopping for car insurance! She finds the best rates and is super knowledgeable…i will always use her…thanks again…
Paul Alvarez
Every experience with We Insure has been a positive one for me. They have taken the time to research my needs and find the best prices available, and that will keep me coming back for life.
Douglas Ford
Kaitlyn did a great job!
Charles Pflueger
Angela and her team are the best insurance agents I’ve ever dealt with.
David Didonato
I like the fact I had plenty of communication with my agent
Adrianne Egbert
Kaitlyn was terrific. So patient with all our questions. Always available!! On a scale of 1-10 she is a googolplex!
Mike Bespalko
Marissa was very helpful and pleasant.
Rachel Withers
We insure is my number one pick for home insurance in the Tampa Bay area. Local team with local knowledge, the people behind the scenes are the best.
Sarah Tapia
My agent Ana was incredibly helpful! She worked really hard to get my needs met and went above and beyond. Thank you Ana!
Denise Jenkins
Kaitlyn was wonderful to work with. She was very friendly and professional. She was also very knowledgeable and provided me with information I wasn’t aware of when looking for flood insurance. She even gave me a contact name to get a wind mitigation report. She was quick to respond to my questions and got me set up with coverage a lot quicker than I was expecting. Thank you so much for the great customer service.
Laura Perry
I would highly recommend Angela Duncan as a broker with We Insure Tampa Bay. She is extremely dedicated and is always searching for the best options for her clients.
Bryan Hepburn
Professional and friendly, quick to reply, and provided detailed responses to our questions. The quote we were given was fair and competitive, we're very satisfied and happy with our interaction and experience with We Insure..
Keriann Ellison
Brittany Miron at We Insure is the absolute best! I invest in real estate, and she got me an amazing rate on my builders risk policy. 800 dollars cheaper than my previous insurer! I am so thrilled with her fast service and she tried every avenue to save me the most money. I will always use her for all of my insurance needs in the future, whether it be home owners insurance or auto insurance as well!
Lilly Sherwood
Kaitlyn was absolutely amazing to work with. She helped my elderly mother with a homeowners policy that included all the coverage she needed as well as a great rate. She was patient and knowledgeable when answering all of the questions we had. We will only be using her moving forward. Thanks again, Kaitlyn!
Paul Alvarez
Angela searched out the best rates for me, and I truly appreciate her dedication to securing a great deal. Thank you!!!
Adrianne Egbert
Kaitlyn Arrington has been so kind, sweet and available to all our questions and needs. On a scale of 1-10, she gets a googolplex!
Kathleen Jaeger
I really appreciated the professionalism being a first time homebuyer