We Insure

PERSONAL INSURANCE

Proven solutions to drive your business forward.

Explore Business

We Insure - Rhodes Insurance Agency

Consultative coverage reviews and straight answers for St Augustine households - without the usual price-only quoting.

We Insure - Rhodes Insurance Agency in St Augustine
Address
109 Nature Walk Parkway, Suite 104, St Augustine, FL 32092
Contact
Hours
M-F 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM

We work with trusted insurance companies.

Progressive
Allstate
Nationwide
Travelers
Liberty Mutual
Geico

Home, Auto, Flood, and More

Common policy types reviewed for clients in St Augustine and nearby communities

Home Insurance icon

Home Insurance

Protects your home, belongings, and liability.

Learn More
Auto Insurance icon

Auto Insurance

Coverage for cars, trucks, and daily drivers.

Learn More
Flood Insurance icon

Flood Insurance

Separate coverage not included in standard home policies.

Learn More
Condo Insurance icon

Condo Insurance

Coverage for your condo, personal property, and liability.

Learn More
RV Insurance icon

RV Insurance

Coverage for motorhomes and travel trailers.

Learn More
Renters Insurance icon

Renters Insurance

Protection for belongings and personal liability.

Learn More
Boat Insurance icon

Boat Insurance

Protection for boats and personal watercraft.

Learn More
Motorcycle Insurance icon

Motorcycle Insurance

Coverage for motorcycles.

Learn More

Ways We Help

1
Annual Policy Reviews
2
Multi-Carrier Quote Comparisons
3
New Homebuyer Consultations
4
Flood Zone Determinations

Ways To Meet

Phone
+1-904-831-8347
Hours
M-F 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM

Areas Served

Based in St Augustine, serving clients across the greater St Augustine area.

Downtown
North Side
South Side
East Side
West Side
Surrounding Areas

About the Owner

Graduated from the University of Florida with a bachelor’s degree of science in recreation 2-20 & 2-15 Licensed Exceptional customer service experience Passionate about educating his clients on the proper way to insure their assets Mike's mission is to offer his clients more choice and better coverage, rates and premium. We Insure represents over 150+ insurance carriers in the state of Florida. We Insure - Rhodes Insurance Agency doesn't just represent one company, they represent you!

Our team takes pride in providing our clients with superior customer service, low rates & the product knowledge necessary to guide you through the insurance buying process. We are located in St. Augustine and would love to help you with your insurance needs. Please think of us for your home, auto, business & every other insurance need.

How this office works

Owner started this office to give St Augustine clients a more consultative insurance experience instead of a quick price-only conversation. The office focuses on: Taking time to ask better questions, understanding what matters to each household, and recommending coverage that actually fits the risk.

What stands out

Consultative coverage reviews instead of price-only quoting

Transparent when another solution is the better fit

What homeowners in St Augustine often miss

A common mistake is assuming flood risk only exists in high-risk zones. In the St Augustine area, the better conversation is understanding the actual risk, the flood zone, and what the policy would do before a storm ever shows up.

What to review

Check flood, wind, and deductible details before storm season instead of waiting until a claim.

Review deductibles, water damage limits, and optional coverages before renewal so nothing important gets missed.

Rated ★★★★★ By Neighbors

"Highly recommend We Insure ! My agent, La-Mar is very knowledgeable and attentive. He always helps me get the best rates !"

Steve Boffoli

"My experience with Sandra Arruda is fantastic. She is an expert in insurance, helps customer understand discounts and guides us to the best options. I totally recommend their services."

Lucia Byers

"Was familiar with Mike Rhodes from my time as a residential home inspector. When I needed coverage for my boat and auto detailing business I chose Mike and was not disappointed. He is very knowledgeable of industry and brokerage requirements and did due diligence finding an affordable general liability quote which is typically challenging to do. Thank you!"

Stephen Brouhard

"Mike and Holli are fantastic. Such attention to detail. Always willing to answer my questions. They are so helpful to shop for me if a rate changes. Their communication can’t be beat. They respond quickly and make you feel like the best client they’ve got. Fantastic people providing excellent service. I’m so thankful I found them, which was on a Facebook group with countless people recommending their fine work. Search no more, Mike and Holli will take care of any of your insurance needs with sincerity and professionalism."

Torrey Pajares

"Mike was very understanding of my needs and found several options based on my risk and financial tolerance. He was also very responsive in his communication."

scott kalan

"Pleasurable experience. Highly recommend"

Arthur Homan

"Mike and Holly were amazing, helping me find home insurance and walking me through the process. Very thankful and I will recommend them to friends and family."

Dzenita Hadzifejzovic

"Fantastic team to deal with"

Garry Hunt

"This agency has saved me thousands a year just this year shopping rates through numerous carriers for auto, home and umbrella policies. Mike is quick to respond and easy to work with. I recommend reaching out to see if he can beat your current rates, you just might be surprised."

Amelia Toal

"Mike was amazing to work with!"

Ryan Trimborn

Local roots in St Augustine

This office has deep St Augustine roots, with team members who have lived and worked in the community for years. We understand the local market and the unique insurance needs of St Augustine residents.

Community involvement includes:

Chamber and local business networking

Community charitable organizations

Local school and youth programs