Your Local Insurance Agent

We Insure Rhodes Insurance Agency

Address Icon


109 Nature Walk Parkway
Suite 104
St. Augustine , FL 32092

Office Hours Icon

Office Hours

M - F 9:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m. 
S - S By Appointment Only 

Download Zogo

Download on the Apple App Store Badge Get it on Google Play Badge

Access code: WEINSURE

Every coverage type for every type of customer

Mike Rhodes


  • Graduated from the University of Florida with a bachelor’s degree of science in recreation
  • 2-20 & 2-15 Licensed
  • Exceptional customer service experience
  • Passionate about educating his clients on the proper way to insure their assets 
Mike's mission is to offer his clients more choice and better coverage, rates and premium. We Insure represents over 150+ insurance carriers in the state of Florida. We Insure - Rhodes Insurance Agency doesn't just represent one company, they represent you!

Our team takes pride in providing our clients with superior customer service, low rates & the product knowledge necessary to guide you through the insurance buying process. We are located in St. Augustine and would love to help you with your insurance needs. Please think of us for your home, auto, business & every other insurance need.

Your local We Insure team

Holli Rhodes

Karen Buttenschon


Your local We Insure reviews

Read More Reviews
Dewayne Major
Holli and Mike Rhodes were extremely knowledgeable in various insurance companies. They assisted me and my husband in the most Professional way. When I call or email and need assistant, they always return my calls or emails in a prompt manner. I would recommend them and their team to everyone. They ROCK!!
Stacey McGrath
Mike Rhodes was extraordinary! He was knowledgeable, quick to respond, super polite and did the most important thing, he helped me shop and find the right insurance for my needs removing the worry from the process. Well done Mike!
Outstanding service! Quick response time. Follow-up questions answered in a very timely manner. Knowledgeable, professional and friendly! Moved our vehicle insurance, homeowners and personal umbrella over to them and saved a lot on our premiums. Thank you Rhodes Insurance Agency!
Debra Morales
Mike and Holli Rhodes were great to work with. During delays in the building process they checked in regularly. They were very responsive and provided several good affordable options for insuring our new home.
Brian Ries
Mike and Holli have been great. 10/10 would recommend.
Diolanda Dasilva
Mike and Holli were great d to talk to right from the start. Answering my questions fully and in a timely manner. I would definitely recommend them to my friends.
Michael Kranz
Professional, fast response time and superb customer service. Mike helped me twice so far. Once for my homeowners insurance and then for my liability insurance for my pressure washing business. He found me the best rates ever and made the process easy and stress free. I will definitely be using him for future needs and highly recommend him to close friends and family!
James Hale
Very informative and friendly service.. Easy to work with and fast. The Rhodes had our best interest in mind. Highly recommend!
Page Pratt
Thanks to Karen Buttenschon at We Insure. She helped get a policy for our property. She did lots of research to find us the best coverage at a great rate. Karen is very friendly, professional, and helpful. Would highly recommend her if you need a new policy or want to compare plans.
Ana Orrego
Easy, professional, quick.
Stacey McGrath
Mike Rhodes was extraordinary! He was knowledgable, quick to respond, super polite and did the most important thing, he helped me shop and find the right insurance for my needs removing the worry from the process. Well done Mike!
Melanie McMullen Rhodes
We were able to switch 6 policies to We Insure - Rhodes Insurance, with a savings on each one! All were handled quick and professionally! Transition was made easily with one phone call and all paperwork done on line. Would definitely, recommend this agency!
Guinevere Mikeylla Soper
Excellent team. Prompt, detailed, very helpful. I will use them forever for my insurance needs from now on .
Anna Gordon
Katie Templeton
Mike & Holli were extremely responsive. They got me great policies and they were super easy to work with.
Michael Aiken
Mike made everything very easy, and found a better rate for me.
Ozlem Soper
Excellent team. Prompt, detailed, helpful. I will use them forever from now on
Christopher Serra
Great people to work with. Very informative and detail oriented. Mike provided me with all the options and explained all the nuances of each. Can’t say enough good things about these folks
Ryan Trimborn
Mike was amazing to work with!
Matt Howell
Mike was awesome! He quickly put my quotes together for me and worked hard to find the best option for my needs!